Showing posts with label Sex. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sex. Show all posts

Tuesday, 12 April 2016

Stephen Fry is Right - We Need to Grow Up

If his critics are right, and if gradation and shades of grey either do not or should not exist, then I have the same right as a victim of a brutal gang rape to be outraged by comments made by Stephen Fry in an interview with US chat show host David Rubin. The same right? No, the same obligation. If his critics are right, I should by now be writhing, crippled by anger. I should have been hurt; I should have been triggered.

For, if his critics are right, rape is rape and abuse is abuse and not only are there no questions left to be asked or answered but anyone stupid, anyone insensitive enough to doubt that inherent truth is a monster; a relic of a less progressive age; a hideous ogre.

So I should be triggered.  I should be. We are all supposed to read from the same Newspeak dictionary, that wonderful thing that frees us from the pain of difficult thoughts by depriving us of the language used to express them.

I have been abused; the victim, I bellyfeel, of sexcrime; and damn the blackwhiters and crimethinkers who duckspeak otherwise.

It – this abuse - has happened on no less than four occasions. Sex whilst one party is inebriated, intoxicated and incapable of giving proper consent, is rape, is it not? That, the exploitation of my own past-penchant for illegal and mind-altering substances, accounts for three of the four; three ‘days-after’ spent regretting to my core that I was too fucked to say no.

The fourth occurred long before. It would be more accurate to call it the first. I was twelve or thirteen, perhaps fourteen, and visiting my uncle in his care home. It was his birthday; we took him a cake and balloons (of which he was once terrified; the chance of bangs and loud noises triggers those occupying his place on the spectrum but he grew up and away from that fear). We were to spend time celebrating with him and his carers and his fellow residents.

Whilst most went into the kitchen, to cut the cake with deliberately blunted knives, I stayed in another room with two of those fellow residents. One was a woman rocking quietly and with earnest intent in the corner. I don’t mind saying that I found her disconcerting; I did. And the other was a man, huge and black. Not fat, just huge. And I found him endearing by comparison. He looked kind and friendly, smiling absent-mindedly as he turned some toy over in his hands.

I was about to leave the room and find the others when that man stood up. I assumed he’d had the same idea and I waited for him to leave first.

Except that he wasn’t leaving, was he. No, he was walking over to me and, pressed up against the wall by his bulk, I felt one large hand, warm and calloused, find its way inside the waistband of my trousers.

It didn’t last long; the hand was hurriedly withdrawn when the rocking woman screeched from the corner. “No! What have we told you about touching!”

And I left the room, nonplussed and a little breathless but otherwise unaffected. I’ve never forgotten the experience and I’d never want to. Looking back, and thankful to that rocking woman who had so alarmed me, I think it is probably the first time the old adage about appearances was made real to me. They can be deceiving. The value of that experience vastly overmatches the occasional chill I get from the memory of it.

I have a vivid imagination. I could ponder here, in writing, what might have happened had the rocking woman not been there. I could speculate as to what might have occurred had I encountered that man not in a care home with my family but in an empty house or a secluded alleyway. It would have been unpleasant. Dare I say worse?

No, I dare not say worse, because that would imply that there are different forms of abuse or severities of rape. And that would be inconceivable, unconscionable in this enlightened day and this progressive age where we are all survivors; where there is no acknowledgeable qualitative difference between an unwanted hand on your cock and a rape at the hands of Jimmy Savile or an entire Somali militia.

It is as if we now live in a culture dedicated to the propagation of trauma. Whereas once we would have looked for ways to overcome what has happened to us, we are now encouraged to feel it as keenly as we can and for as long as we can; to let it define us; to adopt it as an integral part of our identity. We are encouraged to free associate with feeling and to expand our own to encompass the pain and sadness of others.

I say that what happened to me was bad but that it does not begin to compare with what has happened to others. But this new movement would have me say that it does compare, moreover that is the same and so I should feel worse about it. When there is no gradation, when we do not consider relativity in these matters or discriminate between cases, we are forced to elevate the banal and the moderate in order that we not exclude the extreme from this single, unified standard we now operate by. It is all a case, as Fry decries, of black and white, Good and Evil, with all moral nuance dispensed with.

I don’t doubt that this movement, and related cases like #Rhodesmustfall which encourages black students to inherit offences against their ancestors, is sincere in its belief that such conflations are in our best interests and that they serve the common good. It takes a sincere belief in good to breed the most sinister and harmful thoughts and ideologies. As Voltaire is thought to have said “l meglio รจ l'inimico del bene;” They make the best the enemy of the good.

But to understand that is to understand the need to fight against it, to know that the sacrifice of nuance and of good sense and intellectual rigour contributes only to the conflagration of the crimes these movements rail against. Seldom is it a commitment to harm and to evil that drives authoritarian regimes to suppress dissent; they do it because they know that they are right and the dissenters just don’t get it!

But which of the two most resembles the Ogre? It is not Stephen Fry, who argues against the trivialisation of rape that his opponents accuse him of and is undoubtedly better equipped than they of the moral arsenal needed to condemn it. No, the Ogres are the reactionary forces that believe that they are right regardless of their ability to justify it, and who prefer to fall for the easy temptation of censorship than take the difficult path to enlightenment.

As Auden said:

“The Ogre does what ogres can,
Deeds quite impossible for man,
But one prize is beyond his reach:
The Ogre cannot master speech.

About a subjugated plane,
Among its desperate and slain,
The Ogre stalks with hands on hips,
While drivel gushes from his lips.”

Sunday, 24 May 2015

Tory Peer in Call for 'Practical' SRE in Primary Schools.



Conservative peer in call for ‘practical’ sex ed lessons.

The Conservative peer Lord Sleaze is to push ahead with his controversial SRE campaign despite widespread criticism of his proposals. In a speech tomorrow, Lord Sleaze is expected to call for ‘practical instruction’ to be included as part of a scheme entailing mandatory SRE education for primary school pupils.
TNN contacted Mr. Sleaze, who had this to say on the subject.

“Now look. I know this proposal has its critics, but I tell you: I went to a private school; one that was free to pursue its own agenda as regards sex education. They accepted the need for practical lessons as a matter of course. And, clearly, it’s done me no harm. Look at me now!”

Mr. Sleaze, who attended the Bernard Law Catholic School for Boys in Boston, Massachusetts,  before pursuing his political career in the United Kingdom, added that “though the Conservative party is obviously not in favour of lowering the age of consent, or encouraging that kind of thing in general, it is undeniably true that young people are not sufficiently educated in these matters. Education is vital if one is to hold a sensible, informed opinion on anything.”

Mr. Sleaze was unwilling to comment on the reluctance of parliamentarians to introduce compulsory politics, ethics and citizenship classes into the national curriculum.

Critics of his proposal have claimed that primary school children are too young to be educated in matters relating to sex, let alone involved in practical demonstrations. However, the notoriously outspoken peer has been unrepentant. 

“Most of my critics have mothers and fathers who were fourteen or fifteen at the time of conception. So, yes, I suppose I should declare an interest in this matter, as many of these thoughtless cretins wouldn’t have been born had my proposals been enforced two or three decades ago.”

Lord Sleaze has made the news in recent weeks after being linked with the loss of a Home Office dossier containing information of suspected paedophiles within the political system. However, he does not look kindly on those who accuse him of wrongdoing.

“This is exactly why [Home Secretary] Theresa May’s proposed reforms on free speech and the human rights act are necessary,” he said. “This nonsense. This lurid speculation. Of course I wasn’t involved in Operation Cover—err, in this matter. The loss of this document is tragic, to be sure, but to suggest that I had anything to do with it?! Nonsense. Sedition. Seditious nonsense. I’m as fervent an advocate for free speech as anyone you’ll meet, but free speech comes with responsibility. Namely the responsibility not to slander me.”

Lord Sleaze’s speech to UKMBLA UK will be broadcast live on TNNTV from 13:00 tomorrow.