Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts

Sunday, 5 July 2015

Let Them Eat Dog.



Let Them Eat Dog: The Spectacular Hypocrisy of the Anti-Yulin Movement.

“Qu’ils mangent de la brioche” said the great princess. And how contemptibly naïve she was. For those words would hasten forth the ringing of the death knell for the French monarchy.  L’Autrichienne had issued a statement so trite, so appallingly unaware, so out-of-touch with popular opinion in France that the people, the French people, normally so calm and considered and averse to the idea of strikes and demonstrations, had no choice but to revolt.
The mass ‘anti-brioche’ movement had been born, and, with overwhelming verve and vigour, the people signed en-masse a petition condemning such cruelty to Vienoissaries, and calling on the government to ban such a gross demonstration of culinary immorality.  

There followed a revolution, during which sense and decency was restored. Brioche was allowed to live a long and happy life, bread was restored as the basic ingredient in the national diet, and the rest, as they say, is history. 

Except that it isn’t.

For one, the great princess to whom Rousseau attributes that memorable phrase was almost certainly not Marie Antoinette. But that is a minor quibble. No, the most important fact of the matter is that the first iteration of the French Revolution was not a popular reaction to the Dauphine’s goute immorale but a protest against the appalling conditions faced by the French citizenry; conditions that, incidentally, had forced many to resort to far more desperate acts and means than being cruel to man’s best friend. 

The anti-Yulin protest is as inaccurate as the above parody. The Yulin dog-meat festival, a ‘tradition’ that has been celebrated in the Guangxi city of the same name since the mid-‘90s and that received State approval in 2009, might appear to be an expression of particularly poor taste. But, as is so often the case, those campaigning against it are disinclined to explore beneath the surface of the issue. I contend that the festival, and the uncountable equivalents which will escape condemnation by avoiding the attention of viral-moralists, is caused by human suffering. I contend that those who truly wish to see an end to expressions and exercises of barbarous cruelty would better serve their mission by focussing not on one trivial example of it but on that which causes such things to be popular.  

Friends and colleagues have been inclined to highlight the hypocrisy demonstrated by signatories to Change.org and other petitions; those who will lambast the Chinese government for allowing such a festival to occur before settling down in front of the television with a burger made of the less-appetizing remains of a tortured pig or cow or chicken. They are correct to do so. And, as someone who unashamedly salivates over the prospect of a good sausage, I could hardly claim to be bastion of coherent morals if I were myself to have signed the petition. 

But my objection to it, and the particular hypocrisy which I have found most galling, is different. And I should request here, now that I find myself just past the outset, that the reader does not mistake this as a piece by one in favour of battering Chihuahuas to death with sticks and stones. (I am not. Not least because, if the purpose of this capital punishment were that the executioners should be able to devour the carcass, it would be more efficient – it would produce a higher yield - to find and kill a real rat.) Rather, the objection contained herein is to a moral theory that places fluff and paws and cuteness above the rights and liberties of nasty, carnivorous human beings. 

It’s inconvenient, isn’t it? The Chinese… no, the human race in its entirety is not particularly attractive. We’re not fluffy and cuddly. Our noses are often protrusions of unappealing dimensions. Our faces so often lack the features necessary to redeem their lack of symmetry. Our ears are dull, we have hands and not paws, we lack tails, and we are obese and bipedal. And we kill and maim and butcher each other every single day. It’s hard to care, isn’t it? Human suffering produces human apathy. It’s an unpleasant truth, but a truth nonetheless.

But it is worth remembering that China contains perhaps the largest population of disenfranchised people on the planet. Its state, its Party, suppresses dissent with violence and oppresses its people with means that (and clichés are occasionally necessary) can only be described as Orwellian. It brutalizes its ethnic minorities, such as Uyghurs and Tibetans, where it is deemed necessary in order to assuage the Han majority. It is slowly but inexorably bringing its overseas territories and provinces, such as Hong Kong and Taiwan, under the complete control of the mainland, against the wishes of their peoples. This is but one facet of a resurgent, aggressive nationalism that is expressed elsewhere in the form of dangerous and flagrantly illegal irredentism, as demonstrated by the hard line and tough stance taken by The Party in its dispute with Japan over the Senkaku islands, and with territorial disputes in the South China Sea. 

The Party, in an exercise in newspeak reminiscent of Airstrip One, counters claims made about its almost total lack of respect of human rights by international observers, not least those of Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, by saying that it adopts a different definition of the same. The Party defines human rights in relation to the Four Cardinal Principles, which are: 

1. We must keep to the socialist road.
2. We must uphold the dictatorship of the proletariat.
3. We must uphold the leadership of the Communist Party.
4. We must uphold Marxism-Leninism and Mao Zedong Thought.

More recently The Party has expanded its definition. Human rights in China are now considered in relation to its ‘national culture’ and its level of economic growth. (George Osborne would doubtless approve.)

So it is quite proper, says the Party, that China be allowed to execute people (more than every other country that still utilizes capital punishment put together in the ‘90s) who have never seen a trial let alone a jury and then to harvest their organs. It is quite proper that the One Child Policy, and the bizarre and inhumane rules and laws that have spawned from it, should be celebrated; maintained where necessary and redefined elsewhere (with the effect of exacerbating problems of sex-selective back-street abortions and abandonments). It is absolutely right that The Party should maintain strict control of the press, and indeed of all information. It is necessary that it should permit those religious and superstitious practices and traditions that it can control, such as Yulin, whilst seeking to eliminate (in the case of Falun Gong) or impose its own doctrine (in the case of Tibetan Buddhism) on those that defy The Party’s rule. The Party is the religion, and all condoned festivals and ceremonies and traditions are condoned because they conform to its doctrines. More on that later. 

It can maintain the absence of a judicial system and workers’ rights. It can treat its rural and migrant workers as subhumans. It is proper that freedom of political expression and opinion be suppressed and that their advocates be treated as ‘counterrevolutionaries’. It is essential that The Party maintains the myth of a common cultural enemy. Orwell’s dystopia never really required anything other than Goldstein and a one-at-a-time rotation of a foreign foe to achieve this effect, but The Party in China has demonstrated its flexibility in continually coming up with new dangers, new pariahs, new enemies.

I am flirting with crass and artless danger. Perhaps there is already too much paint on the canvas. Suffice it to say that all of the above, and the rest of the exhaustive list that I have not the space or the time to include here, are not just condoned under The Party’s definition of human rights; they are the Party’s definition of human rights. All of this, all of these crimes, are human rights, according to The Party, because they are necessary to ensure the upholding of the Four Cardinal Principles and the continuation of economic growth.

What, then, is the real problem? Is it that some Chinese people (and not, as many Twitter morons seem to believe, the entire population of China) have taken part in the ceremony? Is it that some Chinese people eat dog and cat meat? Rest assured, Yulin does not represent the sum total of animal cruelty and questionable culinary tastes in China. Or is it rather that festivals like Yulin are created, and are popular, because the conditions in which the people of Guangxi are forced to live in, and those of other states and cities and provinces, make them popular? 

Surely it is telling that the official response in China, the state-sponsored backtrack, has coincided not with the advent of a large and international animal rights protest – for the festival has been the subject of international protests for years – but by the involvement of China’s rapidly growing middle class; the social group that is becoming increasingly vital in maintaining the country’s economic growth; the class with access to education; the class with expendable wealth; the class that can afford to keep pets, such as dogs, for pleasure. They have the luxury of being able to afford to care; the money to back the morals.

 I return again to the point made previously; that The Party is, intends, and has always intended to be the religion of China. People will often cite the country as a part of a desperate and misguided attempt to defend the crimes of religion. What they seldom realise is that The Cultural Revolution did not seek to eradicate religion. It sought and it was successful in its quest to adopt the religious impulse itself. It has its own clergy, it has its religious hierarchy, it has its scriptures and its incontrovertible truths and its contempt for free thought and liberty. It is especially ironic that The Party, which still occasionally boasts of its adherence to Marxist-Leninism, is itself the very essence of that which Marx argued so forcefully and ably against.

“Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people.

The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.

Criticism has plucked the imaginary flowers on the chain not in order that man shall continue to bear that chain without fantasy or consolation, but so that he shall throw off the chain and pluck the living flower. The criticism of religion disillusions man, so that he will think, act, and fashion his reality like a man who has discarded his illusions and regained his senses, so that he will move around himself as his own true Sun. Religion is only the illusory Sun which revolves around man as long as he does not revolve around himself.”

That the Yulin festival has been the subject of an international outcry; a great popular movement that claims to decry cruelty, is, then, spectacularly hypocritical. The Yulin festival is but one tradition, one expression, one festival that was created with the express purpose of maintaining the totalitarian religion. In limiting ourselves to attacking its expression, we ignore the fact that the denial of the rights of the Chinese working class to indulge in such activities will only increase the human suffering (and, by extension, the suffering of animals) whilst The Party, the summum malum, that which creates these illusions to glorify itself, remains in power.

A mass movement? Great. A popular revolt? Fantastic. But it is my firm belief that the eliciting of such a sentiment by nothing more substantive than the suffering of a few cute animals is worse than impotent; it is counter-productive.

It is not unworthy of us, it is not a sin, to focus our attention on human suffering, on the abject facts of the human condition, and on the causes of human depredation and exploitation. Perhaps, if we were able to be exercised by these, and if we were capable and more inclined to direct our ire at that which truly deserves it, we might achieve something more meaningful than the downscaling of one minor festival.


 

 

Sunday, 24 May 2015

Tory Peer in Call for 'Practical' SRE in Primary Schools.



Conservative peer in call for ‘practical’ sex ed lessons.

The Conservative peer Lord Sleaze is to push ahead with his controversial SRE campaign despite widespread criticism of his proposals. In a speech tomorrow, Lord Sleaze is expected to call for ‘practical instruction’ to be included as part of a scheme entailing mandatory SRE education for primary school pupils.
TNN contacted Mr. Sleaze, who had this to say on the subject.

“Now look. I know this proposal has its critics, but I tell you: I went to a private school; one that was free to pursue its own agenda as regards sex education. They accepted the need for practical lessons as a matter of course. And, clearly, it’s done me no harm. Look at me now!”

Mr. Sleaze, who attended the Bernard Law Catholic School for Boys in Boston, Massachusetts,  before pursuing his political career in the United Kingdom, added that “though the Conservative party is obviously not in favour of lowering the age of consent, or encouraging that kind of thing in general, it is undeniably true that young people are not sufficiently educated in these matters. Education is vital if one is to hold a sensible, informed opinion on anything.”

Mr. Sleaze was unwilling to comment on the reluctance of parliamentarians to introduce compulsory politics, ethics and citizenship classes into the national curriculum.

Critics of his proposal have claimed that primary school children are too young to be educated in matters relating to sex, let alone involved in practical demonstrations. However, the notoriously outspoken peer has been unrepentant. 

“Most of my critics have mothers and fathers who were fourteen or fifteen at the time of conception. So, yes, I suppose I should declare an interest in this matter, as many of these thoughtless cretins wouldn’t have been born had my proposals been enforced two or three decades ago.”

Lord Sleaze has made the news in recent weeks after being linked with the loss of a Home Office dossier containing information of suspected paedophiles within the political system. However, he does not look kindly on those who accuse him of wrongdoing.

“This is exactly why [Home Secretary] Theresa May’s proposed reforms on free speech and the human rights act are necessary,” he said. “This nonsense. This lurid speculation. Of course I wasn’t involved in Operation Cover—err, in this matter. The loss of this document is tragic, to be sure, but to suggest that I had anything to do with it?! Nonsense. Sedition. Seditious nonsense. I’m as fervent an advocate for free speech as anyone you’ll meet, but free speech comes with responsibility. Namely the responsibility not to slander me.”

Lord Sleaze’s speech to UKMBLA UK will be broadcast live on TNNTV from 13:00 tomorrow.

Thursday, 13 November 2014

Mirror Mirror

Mirror Mirror




Mirror mirror in my hand, who is the fairest in the land?

InstaTwitter and teenagers are reality’s attempt to fill the void occupied in Disneyworld by the magic mirror of fairytales. As is its fashion, reality’s attempt at emulation hasn’t been entirely successful, causing self-esteem to soar to the top of the list of first world problems. And the move has led to a movement, with some online communities taking on the ambitious challenge of affixing the word ‘shaming’ to every noun and adjective in the Oxford English Dictionary.

The evil queen in Snow White didn’t have to deal with this. She occupied a sparsely populated world in which beauty was objectively objective. As such, her magic mirror could, when asked, give her a definitive answer. It could, and did, tell the truth.

Ed Miliband owns a mirror. Nick Robinson was on good form when he interviewed Mr Miliband earlier this week, closing with this very silly question: “When you look in a mirror in the morning, do you see a prime minister?”

Mr Miliband’s response was predictable. “Absolutely!”

This caused me to wonder aloud and to myself for a few minutes. Was he the victim of some fratricidal prank? Had his brother replaced the mirror with a picture of Tony Blair, or even of himself? But I’m prepared to take him at his word, and accept that his mirror is, quite probably, lying to him.

Mr Miliband can perhaps be forgiven for seeking solace by imaginatively augmenting his own reflection. But the mirror is not the polls, and the mirror is not the papers, and the mirror is not his party. Those are the things that matter whether we like it or not, and those are the areas in which Miliband is failing; falling with no style whatsoever.

Let’s proceed in order, and take the polls and papers first:

From the Evening Standard and reported in The Guardian: “The Ipsos Mori research for the Evening Standard found the Conservatives on 32%, Labour on 29%, the Liberal Democrats on 9% and Ukip on 14%. Asked about Miliband as leader, the poll found just 13% of the public think he is ready to be prime minister and his approval rating was lower than that of the Liberal Democrat leader, Nick Clegg.

Among Labour supporters, 58% said they were dissatisfied with his performance as leader... Miliband now has the highest level of dissatisfaction among leaders of his or her own party since records began 20 years ago.”
From The Telegraph: “Only one in 10 women believes that Mr Miliband would be “more respected around the world” than Mr Cameron... Mr Miliband is also failing to convince Labour voters that he is capable of being an effective global statesman.
Only 31 per cent of people who voted Labour in 2010 believe he would be more respected than Mr Cameron, with 20 per cent of Labour voters saying the Conservative leader would be better.
Mr Cameron also beats Mr Miliband by a ratio of two to one on perceptions of his ability to make the right decisions “when the going gets tough”.
The findings suggest that the Labour leader’s personal style is likely to be a drag on his party’s fortunes. By contrast, Mr Cameron still appears to be more popular as a leader than his party.”

And, from The New Statesman: “The picture for Labour in Scotland is looking bleak. Latest polling from Ipsos Mori has found that 52 per cent of Scots will be voting for the SNP in next year’s general election, with only 23% intending to back Labour.” What does this mean for Labour’s chances at the next election? “[In the last week of October] it was estimated that Labour would lose 15 seats to the SNP. Now it could be as many as 36 of their 41 seats – a historic moment of major catastrophe in British politics.”

Granted, most opinion polls are junk. But they do influence public perception, and that, in turn, influences a large number of journalists. Narrative is possibly the closest we are ever likely to get to perpetual motion.

Speaking of journalists – Look at the names of the papers reporting these polls! People who write for The Guardian, The Observer and The New Statesman tend to sympathise with Labour. One expects a good deal of gloating from the likes of the Mail, the Express and The Sun, but support for Mr Miliband in the left-leaning newspapers is lukewarm at best.

Miliband and his team have drawn criticism from the likes of Guardian contributor Roy Greenslade, who had this to say on the Labour leader’s flirtation with The Sun: “The electorate can see through his attempt to find some kind of accommodation with anti-Labour publishers and editors: it reeks of hypocrisy.
There is nothing to be gained from the exercise. Indeed, it's much worse than that. It could cost valuable votes by suggesting that Miliband wants to be all things to all people. It lacks principle.
He goes on to mention criticism of the party leadership from Labour MP Jon Cruddas, which was leaked to The Sunday Times: “[The article] does not, however, mention the crucial argument advanced by Cruddas: the failing of Labour's leadership has been to create "cynical nuggets of policy to chime with our focus groups and press strategy".
“That's a good point, is it not? Miliband's press strategy is informed by a desire to appease anti-Labour newspapers. It is a barren and ultimately flawed strategy.”

Jason Cowley, writing in The New Statesman, is perhaps a little generous when he says that Miliband’s problems are not a result of policy (they are, at least in part) but does acknowledge that the Labour leader has problems with “tone” and that “increasingly he seems trapped.” George Eaton, of the same paper, tows a similar line: Miliband “needs to work on his personal brand.” And Dan Hodges, who professes to be a lifelong Labour supporter, writes in the Telegraph under a headline that includes the sentence “Labour has left itself on the wrong side of every debate.”

It’s not just a handful of disgruntled journalists, either. (The Left has good reason to be disgruntled, but more on that later.) The amount of dirty laundry flying around Victoria Street should come as a surprise to those who remember the hyper-efficient spin machine created and employed to good effect by New Labour.

Miliband has been criticised in public by Lord Prescott of the Working Class for his “timid” strategy and “underwhelming” conference performance. Ed Balls – the shadow chancellor, no less – expressed his “surprise” when Miliband forgot to mention the deficit in that same speech. Margaret Hodge, Tessa Jowell and Diane Abbott have all voiced doubts about Miliband’s proposed mansion tax. (All three are considering running for Mayor of London, but the issue, as far as leadership is concerned, is not that these people are being disingenuous but that they are doing it in public.) As if that weren’t enough, an article in the Observer on November 9th claimed that the magazine had been approached by three “senior Labour MPs.” They spoke under condition of anonymity, and their claims should be treated with scepticism, but the article states that “at least 20” shadow ministers are “on the brink of calling for him to stand down.”

“There is a significant number of frontbenchers who are concerned about Ed’s leadership – or lack of leadership – and would be ready to support someone who is a viable candidate.” Their preferred candidate is the lovable Alan Johnson, though he has attempted to distance himself from the rebel alliance.

Those attempting to defend Miliband have contributed to his troubles. The likes of Neil Kinnock seem to think that the most effective strategy is to tell the dissenters to “shut up and deal with it.” Hardly a ringing endorsement, and the attention it has drawn seems to have hindered the loyalists’ case.

Meanwhile, the award for the most incompetent defense goes to Tristram Hunt for this remarkable effort: “I never believed the answer to Labour’s problems was to show people more of Ed Miliband. It was a ridiculous idea dreamed up by his advisers who have served him badly... It has been a complete failure. It is making things worse, not better. Ed has excellent qualities but that is not the way to show them. It is absurd.” (He then took to Twitter to claim that he’d been misrepresented. He wasn’t misrepresented, he was careless. Either he wants Miliband to be an invisible leader or he does not.)

Politics should be about substance, not image or personality. I know. It’s a well-worn phrase. Miliband has said it himself. "David Cameron is a very sophisticated and successful exponent of a politics based purely on image... I am not going to be able to compete with that and I don't intend to... I am not from central casting. You can find people who are more square-jawed, more chiselled. Look less like Wallace.”

Nothing to disagree with there.

I also know that it is far too easy to make cheap jokes at his expense. We can all do it. He has the smile of a serial killer, or the distant relative you’ve heard all those stories about. His face wouldn’t look out of place in a Dali exhibition, and so on.

But this is a man who still insists on making a mess of the very thing he claims to be against. This is the man who flirts with the Sun, who is physically incapable of eating a sandwich, who can give the same answer to four different questions in one interview, who makes giving money to the homeless look bad, and who is so obsessed with style that he thinks a good speech is one given without notes. (That particular stunt drew criticism from Len McCluskey, of all people.) This is a man who can’t even demonstrate hypocrisy properly!

He cannot lead his own party. He has alienated his supporters. He cannot handle the press. He will not challenge austerity. He will not debate Europe. He will not challenge the TTIP. He cannot challenge an unpopular Tory party. He offers nothing to the working class. He offers no Left alternative. He offers no alternative.

His magic mirror may lie to him, but it seems reality will not. If Labour win the next election, it will be in spite of their leader, not because of him. Some people warrant their ‘shaming’.












Tuesday, 11 November 2014

To Play the Queen: The Case Against Hillary Clinton - Part 2.

To Play the Queen.

The case against Hillary Clinton - Part 2.

During the time I have spent writing this, the second part of the précis of a case against Hillary Clinton, an American friend and occasional correspondent - and a potential Clinton voter - posed me three questions, which can be fairly summarised as follows:

1) Is it not both unfair and irrelevant to focus so much of my argument on Clinton's personal life?
2) Is it not the case that her tenure as Secretary of State has given her the experience necessary to manage the office of President?
3) Would it not be good for the United States to elect its first female president and, more broadly, is she not likely to be better than anyone (Bachman, Bush, Cain, Christie, Paul, Ryan, etc.) running as a Republican?

The sentiment of these questions is more important than the content because it mirrors that expressed by the supporters and defenders of Bill Clinton throughout his tenure as president, and because we are likely to see similar arguments proffered by the votaries of Hillary Clinton. They, like their forebears in the nineties, will almost certainly claim (with hurt in their eyes and pain in their voices) that those who hold and express views like my own are demonizing their preferred candidate who, let's not forget, "has done so much for us!"
My first response went something like this: If you can look at the charges put by myself and others and still hold the view that they are vulgar personal attacks, and that they bear no relevance to Ms Clinton's political career and aspirations, then that is very much your problem, and you will likely be rewarded with exactly what you deserve.

That said, and in case my answer be deemed to evasive or dismissive, I intend to incorporate more detailed answers to these questions within the next – and final – part of this series. If by its conclusion the reader feels that any of the above have been left unanswered, then either I have failed in my task, or you have failed in yours.

So, without any further meandering:

6) The Brothers Rodham.

"If my sister doesn’t end up with the nomination, I gotta take a look at who I’m gonna vote for.”
So said Tony Rodham to a reporter from the LA Times, who found him stewing over a pint at a bar opposite the Washington hotel which was playing host to the Democratic rules committee.

To the uninitiated, this might seem a trivial anecdote; an expression of brotherly bias, and nothing more. To those on the Clinton staff, a Rodham brother mouthing off to a journalist is seen as a minor crisis.
Never mind that his preferred candidate, should Hillary not get the Democratic nomination, was John McCain or Bob Barr (both Republicans, and the ease with which a Clinton or a Rodham can make the transition from Democrat to Republican is a theme which runs throughout both houses); the Rodham brothers are bad news.

If one looks through newspaper archives or on the internet, one is struck by how many gaffes and scandals and sinister dealings that Tony and Hugh Rodham are associated with. That their plans and designs almost always end in failure is testament to their incompetence, for which the United States owes a debt of gratitude to nature, which has been so unkind to them.

One of the most amusing and well known episodes came when the brothers put their collective brain to the task of creating and orchestrating what we are obliged to call a 'get rich quick' scheme. This involved the peculiar and, at first glance, innocuous enterprise of growing hazelnuts in the former Soviet state of Georgia, and exporting them to the West.

In a feat befitting of a comic relief duet, this banal venture caused a major diplomatic scandal.
The brothers had, more by accident than design, embroiled themselves in the complex world of post-Soviet politics. The Clinton administration had gone to considerable efforts to support the then-president of Georgia Eduard Shevardnadze, who was accommodating of US interests in the region.

The Rodham brothers, apparently ignorant of this delicate state of affairs, bypassed the government of Georgia and went instead to the president's great rival, the pro-Russian Aslan Abashidze (a man who more closely resembles an egg than a lion). Abashidze took the opportunity to flaunt what he claimed was the personal support of Bill Clinton, which unsettled Shevardnadze, and this in turn compromised relations between the US and Georgia.

Tony Rodham seems to have acted as the puppet of a disreputable Georgian gentleman named Vasili Patarkalishvili. This is the man responsible for the conception of the hazelnut plan, as well as the founder of a bank which opened just long enough to take hundreds of thousands of dollars before closing (with the money still somewhere inside), and who attempted to use Tony's influence to arrange a meeting between Bill Clinton and the then-mayor of Moscow Yuri Luzhkov, with the aim of winning Luzhkov's support for another shady scheme involving smart debit cards. Luzhkov, incidentally, was rumoured to have links to mobsters, and allegedly had an American businessman murdered.

Hugh, meanwhile, has been accused of using his influence to negotiate a lucrative tobacco settlement, and both have been accused of acting as covert lobbyists for various interest groups, taking a significant amount of money in the process.

7) The Issue of Race.

No, I'm not talking about the 'race card' supposedly played by Obama on Bill Clinton. He can claim otherwise, but the former president (who later attempted to deny saying what, thanks to the internet, we can still clearly hear him saying) betrayed another less-than-clean aspect of his character.

The Clintons have never been shy of deploying race as a tactic. Bill Clinton did it in 1992, making overtures to minorities and then veering sharply away to reassure the rednecks. The 1994 “white hands” TV advert, authored by that most capable of Clinton stooges Dick Morris, deliberately played on a particularly nasty kind of race-based animosity; exploiting the plight of the white working classes and directing their ire at the job-stealing minorities. He launched something like an attack on Jesse Jackson and his Rainbow Coalition via the proxy of Sister Souljah in 1992, whilst the execution of Ricky Ray Rector served a double purpose: it made him look tough at a time when his credibility was threatened by the Gennifer Flowers affair, and it appealed to the more stupid and sadistic of his voters in the most visceral way possible. "Look, I'm not too pro-black; here I am supervising the execution of a black man.”

Bill Clinton's record on this is perhaps worse than that of his wife, but we must remember that he was officially a part of her campaign team. We must also remember that the odds of Bill joining the White House as an advisor to his wife are exceedingly good. (We live in a world in which the opinions of someone like Barbra Streisand – one of the few women besides Hillary to have been close to the president who hasn’t later attempted to sue him, or join the law suits of others – are taken seriously.) The ‘whites only’ golf club might have been forgotten by the voters, but we have no reason to abandon our doubts about his character in this regard.

Hillary Clinton adopted a slightly more nuanced approach, making the occasional reference, but rarely doing anything more explicit than implying or insinuating that Obama was and is too black to be a president.
Take this, for example: "Sen. Obama's support among working, hardworking Americans, white Americans, is weakening again," she told the paper, citing as evidence a recent Associated Press story on voting trends in Indiana and North Carolina. "I have a much broader base to build a winning coalition on."

And Bill eventually began towing the less conspicuous line, saying this in North Carolina: "I think it'd be a great thing if we had an election year where you had two people who loved this country and were devoted to the interest of this country. And people could actually ask themselves who is right on these issues, instead of all this other stuff that always seems to intrude itself on our politics." That said, his unprompted comparison between Obama's victory and those of Jesse Jackson in the 80s does not really deserve to be called a 'veiled reference"
.
8) Under Fire in Bosnia?

Despite her appeals for clemency and understanding (because the campaign trail is long and tiring, whilst the office of president is, presumably, a breeze by comparison), Ms Clinton did not simply 'misspeak' when she fabricated a record for herself in Bosnia.

Here is one version of her claim, from a speech at George Washington University in 2008:
"I remember landing under sniper fire. There was supposed to be some kind of a greeting ceremony at the airport, but instead we just ran with our heads down to get into the vehicles to get to our base."

If you are going to lie in an attempt to boost your credentials, it is probably best to choose something that is hard to prove or disprove. It is certainly not a good idea to lie about a trip on which you were accompanied by an entire camera crew from the broadcaster CBS, the singer Sheryl Crowe, and the comedian Sinbad.
The CBS footage has been uploaded to Youtube and juxtaposed with the comments made by Ms Clinton as seen above. It makes for an amusing watch but, for those readers who do not have instant access to the internet, here is a brief description of what actually occurred, written by Michael Dobbs of the Washington Post's 'The Fact Checker' blog:

"As a reporter who visited Bosnia soon after the December 1995 Dayton Peace agreement, I can attest that the physical risks were minimal during this period, particularly at a heavily fortified U.S. Air Force base, such as Tuzla. Contrary to the claims of Hillary Clinton and former Army secretary Togo West, Bosnia was not "too dangerous" a place for President Clinton to visit in early 1996. In fact, the first Clinton to visit the Tuzla Air Force base was not Hillary, but Bill, on January 13, 1996.
Had Hillary Clinton's plane come "under sniper fire" in March 1996, we would certainly have heard about it long before now. Numerous reporters, including the Washington Post's John Pomfret, covered her trip. A review of nearly 100 news accounts of her visit shows that not a single newspaper or television station reported any security threat to the First Lady. "As a former AP wire service hack, I can safely say that it would have been in my lead had anything like that happened," said Pomfret.
According to Pomfret, the Tuzla airport was "one of the safest places in Bosnia" in March 1996, and "firmly under the control" of the 1st Armored Division.
Far from running to an airport building with their heads down, Clinton and her party were greeted on the tarmac by smiling U.S. and Bosnian officials. An eight-year-old Moslem girl, Emina Bicakcic, read a poem in English. An Associated Press photograph of the greeting ceremony... shows a smiling Clinton bending down to receive a kiss."
Well, her head was down. But, flippancy aside, I draw the reader's attention to what I wrote in the first part of this case. (It's called A House of Lies and it can be found in the previous issue of the Lion, or on my blog.) Hillary Clinton is at least partly responsible for the Clinton administration (temporarily) reneging on its promise to end the campaign of rape, murder and genocide carried out against the Bosnians under the auspices of Ratko Mladic and Slobodan Milosevic. That Clinton had the gall to repeatedly lie about her role in Bosnia, and to try and claim the country, its people, and the atrocities committed against them as political capital to further her own cause is, to put it politely, egregious in the extreme.


9) Dodgy Donors & Farcical Financiers.

Well, where does one begin to tackle this subject?

“The story behind story is that America is in an era of sharply rising inequality, with a few at the top doing fabulously well but most Americans on a downward economic escalator.

That’s why Diane Sawyer asked Hillary about the huge speaking fees, and why the Guardian asked whether she could be credible on the issue of inequality.

And it’s why Hillary’s answers – that the couple needed money when they left the White House, and have paid their taxes and worked hard for it — seemed oddly beside the point. 

The questions had nothing to do with whether the former first couple deserved the money. They were really about whether all that income from big corporations and Wall Street put them on the side of the privileged and powerful, rather than on the side of ordinary Americans.”

Robert Reich, once a friend of the Clintons and Secretary of Labor in their administration, was probably correct in his analysis. The fuss following Hillary Clinton’s absurd claim – that the family was ‘broke’ after leaving the White House – was largely due to the fact that, for a great many Americans, the term ‘broke’ entails an inability to pay rent and feed the family.

As noted by Philip Bump in The Washington Post: “In 2000, the couple had no more than $2 million in assets, but perhaps as much as $10 million in debt... But if the couple was broke as they walked out of the White House, it took very little time to recover financially. In 2001, Bill made $13 million in speaking fees, and Hillary brought in nearly $2.5 million, presumably from her advance for "Living History." By 2004, the debt was erased.”

The article, which can be found here, notes that a significant portion of the $10 million in debt can be attributed to legal fees.

As is his fashion, Mr Reich does not care to look beyond the biggest of big pictures. The ‘tempest’, as he puts it, might not have been “about how they earned their money,”  but perhaps it should have been. Perhaps it would have been, too, had people like Mr Reich deigned to tell us exactly what caused those legal fees to soar, and how the Clinton’s have so often chosen to pay their debts.

Let’s start with the obvious.

Ms Clinton will almost certainly run in 2016, and much of her campaign infrastructure will be funded by Super PACs created by a group of people – former and current advisers, business associates, and the like – that we might loosely call ‘friends of the family’. This was made possible when, in 2010, the Supreme Court voted to ease restrictions on spending by ‘outside political organisations’.

This has not stopped her indulging in what her friends on Wall Street call ‘progressive populism’. In April this year, she criticised SCOTUS for “removing a limit on the total number of candidates one can donate to in one election season;” a move likely to mean that more private money enters the realm of electoral politics.

But I hope that the reader is not so easily fooled. There’s a reason Citigroup, Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan occupy first, second and fourth place on a list of Ms Clinton’s donors. There’s a reason these companies will pay $200,000 for such insights as “Leadership is a team sport,” “You can’t win if you don’t show up,” and “A whisper can be louder than a shout.” And there’s a reason that, in July of this year, a front-page article in the New York Times opened with the following: “As its relationship with Democrats hits a historic low, Wall Street sees a solution on the horizon: Hillary Rodham Clinton.”

This is Hillary’s Triangulation. It doesn’t really deserve to be called a variant of the Clintonian model, because it differs from the strategy of the Nineties in no meaningful respect. It is, after all, a family business, and Hillary herself employed it in a move that would see healthcare consolidated in the hands of a select few insurance companies.

I turn to Christopher Hitchens who, in No One Left To Lie To, summarises this episode of Triangulation more effectively than I can. He quotes a speech made by Ms Clinton in 1993 which closes as follows: “What you don’t get told [in adverts attacking the proposals for healthcare reform] is that it is paid for by insurance companies. It is time for you and for every American to stand up and say to the insurance industry: “Enough is enough, we want our health-care system back!”

He then goes on to make the following observation: “It is fortunate for the Clintons that this populist appeal was unsuccessful. Had the masses risen up against the insurance companies, they would have discovered that the four largest of them— Aetna, Prudential, Met Life, and Cigna— had helped finance and design the “managed-competition” scheme which the Clintons and their Jackson Hole Group had put forward in the first place.”

“The ‘triangulation’”, he says, “went like this. Harry and Louise sob-story ads were paid for by the Health Insurance Association of America (HIAA), a group made up of the smaller insurance providers. The major five insurance corporations spent even more money to support “managed competition” and to buy up HMOs as the likeliest investment for the future. The Clintons demagogically campaigned against the “insurance industry,” while backing— and with the backing of— those large fish that were preparing to swallow the minnows.”

(Back to the present: This perhaps goes some way toward explaining Ms Clinton’s reaction to the SCOTUS decision mentioned earlier. She claimed, in the same speech, that: "With the rate the Supreme Court is going, there will only be three or four people in the whole country that have to finance our entire political system by the time they are done." We’ll ignore, at least for the moment, the fact that Ms Clinton is describing the status quo and not the future. Her problem with the SCOTUS decision is that it leaves those three or four people free to donate to candidates who aren’t her. In 93 she could monopolise the support of Aetna, Prudential and Cigna, and until recently she could monopolise the support of Goldman Sachs and Citigroup. Though it has by no means destroyed it, SCOTUS has ensured that she will have to work a little harder to maintain this monopoly.)

The same author published an essay in The Nation in 2000, in which he makes mention of donations to Ms Clinton from the Pakistani government, made via the law firm of another family friend.

“Remember when every liberal knew how to sneer at George W. Bush, not only for forgetting the name of Pakistan’s new dictator but for saying that he seemed like a good guy? Well , General Musharraf’s regime has now hired, at a retainer of $ 22,500 per month, the DC law firm of Patton Boggs, for which Lanny Davis, one of the First Family’s chief apologists, toils.
Perhaps for reasons having to do with the separation of powers, Patton Boggs also collects $ 10,000 monthly from Pak-Pac, the Pakistani lobby in America, for Davis’s services in its behalf. Suddenly, no more Dem jokes about ignorance of Pakistan. Last December, after Clinton announced that Pakistan would not be on his itinerary when he visited the subcontinent, his former White House “special counsel” arranged a fundraiser in Washington at which lawyers from Patton Boggs made contributions to the First Lady’s Senate campaign that now total $ 25,500. So, not very indirectly, Pakistani military money was washed into her coffers from the very start. Then, in February, another Pak-Pac event, in New York, was brought forward so as to occur before the arrangements for the President’s passage to India had been finalized. Having been told that the First Lady did not grace any event for less than $ 50,000 upfront, the Pakistanis came up with the dough and were handsomely rewarded for their trouble by the presence of Lanny Davis and by a statement from Mrs. Clinton that she hoped her spouse would stop off in Pakistan after all. And a few days later, he announced that, after much cogitation, he would favor General Musharraf with a drop-by.”

Moving both forwards and backwards through time in a manner only marginally more ridiculous than an entry from The Hitch Hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy: Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign in 2008 was haunted by a ghost from 1996, when Norman Hsu, a Clinton campaign “bundler” (and who, along with the likes of Elton John and Steven Spielberg, rose to the title of “Hillraiser”), was revealed to be a fugitive from justice. He had failed to appear for sentencing after being convicted of fraud in 1992 and, after a report in The Wall Street Journal alleged that he had ‘mishandled’ a considerable amount of bundled campaign finance contributions, he disappeared again.

The Clinton team can, if you’ll forgive the bad play on words, be said to have “bungled” its response to the Hsu scandal. It supported him, then it distanced itself, then it supported him, then it distanced itself again. It announced it would return the donations, then it would return some of the donations, then it would return only the donations relating to the 2008 campaign and not those made for Ms Clinton’s re-election campaign in 2006, for which Mr. Hsu also served as a “bundler.”

Fair enough, one might possibly forgive this oversight. It was a busy campaign, and Ms. Clinton had an inexplicably large number of donors. It wasn’t quite at the level of the 1996 campaign finance scandal, in which somewhere in the region of 50 donors with links to the Chinese military-industrial complex fled the country rather than appear before the senate, a good deal more pleaded the 5th amendment, and the likes of Charlie Trie, Johnny Chung and Maria Hsia were eventually compelled to give us a glimpse of a huge and murky network of illegitimate donors to the DNC and the Clinton campaign. (That this scandal concluded without a conclusion is testament in part to the work of Janet Reno.) However, when you consider that the 2008 campaign hadn’t even considered performing background checks on its largest donors, one has cause for suspicion. And when you add contributions from Abdul Rehmann Jinnah, William Danielczyk, the Tamil Rehabilitation Organization (believed to be a front for the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam, which the United States lists as a terrorist organisation) and hundreds of thousands of dollars from the poorest households in New York’s Chinatown (the LA Times report features imaginary people, Chinese crime syndicates, exploitation of migrants and many more unpleasant realities), the whole episode takes on a distinctly sinister tone.

It has dawned on me that I will close this lengthy section having not even touched on Whitewater or the cattle-future trades. (The latter was just one of the occasions on which Ms Clinton used her daughter as a shield. In this case, she hadn’t even been born!)



10) Unanswered Questions.

I turn to Robert Scheer of The Nation to sum this up. On the NSA:
"Did Secretary of State Clinton know that such massive spying on the American people was going on and, if not, why isn’t she grateful that Snowden helped to enlighten her? With her scurrilous attacks on Snowden, Hillary Clinton is either a fool or a liar."

And, alas, I am out of space.